Regional newspaper Hall of Fame

Eric Price

In the last few weeks, we have lost three giants of the regional Press. Former Western Daily Press editor Eric Price's death last week came only two weeks after Walter Greenwood died and a month after the death of David Williams,  the campaigning editor of the Evening Argus in Brighton. In five weeks the Regional Press's Hall of Fame lost three of its members. The Hall of Fame was put together in 2006 when Ian Reeves, then editor of the Press Gazette, asked me to chair a panel to select the 40 people who had made the most significant contribution to regional journalism in the last 40 years. It was to celebrate the Press Gazette's 40th anniversary. The first challenge was the panel. Its members had to have seniority, they had to be long-serving and be representative of geographical areas and newspaper groups. There were seven of us: Manchester Evening News editor, Paul Horrocks, former Cumbrian Newspapers editorial director Keith Sutton, Trinity Mirror editorial director Neil Benson, former Western Daily Press editor and editors' code committee secretary Ian Beales, former York Evening Press editor Liz Page who was with Archant at the time and Johnston Press editorial executive David Rowell.

Then there was the criteria - the nominees had to be journalists. We also didn't want this to just become a list of long-serving editors so writers, photographers, columnists, subs, cartoonists had to be considered. I asked the panel members, when they were mulling over the 120 names before us, to think about what the intro would be. If it was simply 'They served the paper for 18 years and remained committed to the Guild of Editors', it was unlikely they would make the cut. We wanted people who had made a difference. Press Gazette readers were also invited to send in nominations.

Ian Reeve said at the time: "On completion of their task, the panel winced about the shortage of women which, although uncomfortable, reflects the reality of the years in question. There were also few working editors. Is this because we halo our predecessors rather than our peers or is it that today's editors are less inclined to put their heads above the parapet? Maybe it was because the panel were uncertain, as they were only part way through their tenure, how history would judge them".

The first 25 names were easy, the second 15 almost impossible. We discussed them long into the night, had heated words, and then came back for more. We finally settled on 40 names. Those still alive were invited to the Regional Press Awards and framed portraits of each one were hung on the wall. The intention was to add someone each year.

A booklet containing a commissioned article on each of the 40 was produced. The deaths of Eric, Walter and David encouraged me to go through my old files and retrieve it. It is still a fascinating read. But it really does feel as though it belongs to a totally different age. It shows the massive changes there have been in our industry in the last seven years. If we did the exercise again, would we choose the same 40? I wonder. Perhaps the Press Gazette, which will be celebrating its 50th anniversary in 2015, should resurrect the idea.

Here is the list, in alphabetical order, along with the headlines from the booklet.

Mike Amos, MBE (Northern Echo columnist)

Legendary columnist and local celebrity who, for many, personifies his paper

Barry Askew (editor, Lancashire Evening Post and News of the World. Died 2012)

A colourful editor who never passed up an opportunity to shake up the establishment

Colin Brannigan, OBE (editor, Sheffield Star; md, Essex County Newspapers)

Campaigning innovator who was ahead of his time and a passionate advocate of local content

Frank Branston (founder, Bedfordshire on Sunday. Died 2009)

From sarcastic Sunday Express office boy to multi-millionaire mayor of Bedford

Roger Cross (crime specialist, Yorkshire Post; author, The Yorkshire Ripper. Died 1994)

Larger than life character and accomplished raconteur who produced a stream of Yorkshire exclusives

Ed Curran (editor-in-chief, Belfast Telegraph and Sunday Life)

Ace Ulster journalist who remains on first name terms with all sides

Sean Dooley (editor, Gloucestershire Echo and The Sentinel, Stoke)

Shrewd editor who transformed Stoke daily and launched ground-breaking Sunday

Ian Dowell, MBE (editor, Birmingham Evening Mail)

People's champion who was not afraid of taking on the big guns on behalf of the readers

Geoff Elliott, CBE (editor Kent Messenger, Coventry Telegraph, The News, Portsmouth; head of journalism, University of Central Lancashire)

Pace-setter of journalistic standards with a passion for excellence, integrity and determination

Sir Harold Evans (editor, The Northern Echo, The Sunday Times and The Times; author of many books on journalism)

Possibly the greatest editor of all time, set the standard for campaigning journalism

Peter Franzen, OBE (editor, Eastern Daily Press)

Transformed an old-fashioned broadsheet into the first compact newspaper

Stuart Garner (editorial director and chief executive, Thomson Regional Newspapers)

Steely nerve and willingness to make big decisions

John Gibson (sports writer, Evening Chronicle, Newcastle; executive sports editor Newcastle Chronicle & Journal Ltd)

The North-East's larger than life sports reporter who won the respect and trust of players and fans

Walter Greenwood (head of Thomson Regional Newspapers training centre; co-author of Essential Law for Journalists for 27 years. Died 2013)

The man to turn to for expert advice on court reporting laws

Bill Heeps (chief executive and chairman, Thomson Regional Newspapers. Died 1995)  

Tireless toubleshooter who oversaw a revolution in new technology

Nick Herbert, Lord Hemingford (editor, Cambridge Evening News; editorial director, Westminster Press)

Inspirational editorial director who gave the best possible advice

Ron Hunt, MBE (editor, Northamptonshire Evening Telegraph; executive editor of EMAP newspapers; editor, Diss Express)

He brought out his evening paper single-handedly during a long strike

Bob James (lecturer, typographer, designer, author, development editor with Westminster Press. Died 2004)

He knew all there was to know about typography and kick-started a new era in training

Grenfell Jones (Gren), MBE (cartoonist, South Wales Echo. Died 2007)

South Wales's most eminent cartoonist who brought a daily smile to readers

Alex Leys (editor Lincolnshire Echo, Derby Telegraph, Leicester Mercury; founding editor UK News; editorial director at Northcliffe)

The first of a new Northcliffe breed that shook the regional newspaper world

Peter Long (launch editor, Chester Tonight; editor-in-chief of Celtic Newspapers)

His brave innovations revitalised titles in the South Wales Valleys

Toby Melville (photographer Bristol United Press, Press Association, Reuters)

Photojournalist with a natural ability to capture every mood at its fullest

Maureen Messent (columnist, Evening Mail, Birmingham)

Colourful writer who could be hard-nosed inquisitor or tearful agony aunt

Peter Moore (editor, Grimsby Telegraph. Died 2004)

Campaigning editor who always had time for his readers and staff

Jean Morgan (reporter, UK Press Gazette)

Intrepid reporter scared management and never failed to get the big stories

Chris Oakley, CBE (editor, Liverpool Echo; editor-in-chief Birmingham Post & Mail; chief executive Midland Independent Newspapers and Regional Independent Media)

Editor-turned-entrepreneur who helped transform the regional Press

Steve Panter (crime reporter and news-editor, Manchester Evening News)

Fearless crime reporter who risked jail to protect source

Ian Park, CBE (editor-in-chief and md Liverpool Post & Echo; chief executive and chairman, Northcliffe Newspapers)

Sharp, disciplined executive both feared and revered by editors

Keith Parker, OBE (editor, md Express & Star, Wolverhampton. Died 2010)

Editor whose superb standards resulted in huge rises in circulation

Paul Potts (editor-in-chief and chief executive, Press Association)

Indefatigable journalist who became boss who transformed PA group

Eric Price (editor, Western Daily Press; editorial director, Bristol Evening Post. Died 2013)

Miracle worker who transformed the fortunes of the West Country's top title

Allan Prosser (editor, The Northern Echo; editorial director, Kent Messenger Group; md of North of England Newspapers)

Powerhouse who saw off all detractors to modernise and reinvigorate a great daily

Terry Quinn (editor, Bradford T&A, Evening News, Edinburgh, Daily Record; editorial director, Thomson Regional Newspapers)

Driven editor and creative thinker who refused to take no for an answer

Bob Satchwell (editor, Cambridge Evening News; executive director, Society of Editors)

Incisive editor who has become battling leader of Society of Editors

Stephen Shakeshaft (photographer and picture editor, Liverpool Post & Echo)

An illuminating lensman capturing the biggest stars and ordinary people

Anita Syvret (editor, Gloucestershire Echo)

Pioneering female daily newspaper editor who survived by putting readers first

Tony Watson (editor, Yorkshire Post; editorial director and md, the Press Association)

Young editor presided over a new golden age for venerable Yorkshire institution

Tom Welsh (editor Evening Mail, Barrow; director of journalism at City University; co-author of Essential Law)

Co-author of the journalists' law bible and a prominent voice for Press freedom

Barrie Williams (editor, Kent Evening Post, Nottingham Evening Post and Western Morning News)

Brought a single-minded passion to his three long editorships

David Williams (editor, Brighton Evening Argus and Bury Free Press. Died 2013)

Inspired and brave editor who rolled up his sleeves and led from the front

Walter Greenwood: the journalist's legal guide

Walter Greenwood had a huge influence on many generations of journalists. He changed the face of journalism training, was instrumental in the careers of Andrew Marr, James Naughtie, Lionel Barber, Sally Magnusson and Michael Gove and he co-edited Essential Law for Journalists for 30 years. I met Walter a few times and always found him professional, charming and great company. But others knew him far better. So I asked my colleague Tony Johnston to pay tribute to Walter. 

Walter accepts the Journalists' Charity Special Award from Amy Williams and John Humphrys at the Press Awards in 2010

Encyclopaedic knowledge, a love of law and a sharp wit

By Tony Johnston

Tributes have been pouring in from across the world to Walter Greenwood, who helped so many journalists cope with the perils of media law. Walter, who died on Sunday at the age of 87 after a 12-month battle with ill health, had an encyclopaedic knowledge of every statute that can impact on what we publish. Editors and newsdesks would turn to him at all times of day and night, looking for guidance to help them get their stories into print safely.
He helped found the Thomson Regional Newspapers training centre in Newcastle, which I now manage for the Press Association.
He continued to take a close interest in each course, setting exams and teaching Scots Law until last year when he was struck down by serious illness.
He was once asked what his childhood ambitions had been – a career in law or a newsroom? Growing up in Dewsbury, he had only one ambition, was his reply. And that was to get out of Dewsbury.
He joined his local newspaper, the Dewsbury Reporter, at the age of 16.
Two years later, called up for National Service, he hoped to join the RAF and was disappointed to be randomly selected to work as a Bevin Boy. He spent three and a half years in the mines, after which he had no hesitation in returning to his beloved newsroom.
Pat Hagan, law tutor in Newcastle, recalls how his love of work was legendary.
She said: “Holidays would not have been complete without it. His choice of holiday destination was dictated not by the weather or the tourist attractions; it was determined by the availability of his morning copy of The Times and a fax machine, to deal with the law queries that would surely come. And they invariably did.
“Walter had a phenomenal memory, recalling not only every particular of media law, but which page of his beloved Essential Law spelt it out to the rest of us. Asked how it was that he could remember it all in such minute detail, he would concede that when it came to the law, he could usually remember what he needed to; it was in trying to remember what he had had for breakfast that he sometimes faltered. 
“This was not necessarily true. 
“During a long hospital stay just before Christmas, a framed holiday snap of him had been placed on his bedside table. It had been taken more than 30 years ago. Anyone remarking on how dapper and contented he looked would be told the photograph had been taken after a rather long and enjoyable lunch. And what had he had for lunch? Sea bass, was the reply.
As Pat explained, his wit, self-deprecating humour and love of the law persisted through even his final illness.
Encouraged by physiotherapists to exercise his limbs as well as his mind, he gleefully recounted how one hapless young woman had challenged him to construct a sentence of 30 words. And had he been able to manage it? He certainly had; he had “provided a short introduction to the law of libel”. 
Pat said: “Walter took great delight in sharing his legal expertise with trainee reporters – a delight that extended to the point where he appeared to relish the prospect of marking exam scripts, no matter how high the pile or how tight the deadline. Settling himself at a desk at Press Association Training after one particularly tough exam, he produced a light lunch of fresh fruit from his briefcase and proceeded to get down to work. All he needed now was a small glass of red wine and he would be complete, he quipped. A small glass of red wine was quickly secured. 
“And there he stayed until the task was complete, sipping his wine, confounded by yet another trainee who appeared unable to grasp the difference between defamation and contempt. He would make a note of it and resolve to have a quiet word when the time was right.”
Walter is survived by his wife Doreen. They would have celebrated their diamond wedding anniversary on October 23.

Other tributes to Walter include the following:

The Evening Chronicle, Newcastle
The Guardian
The Daily Telegraph
The BBC
Sky 
The Prolific North
Hold The Front Page
The Press Gazette

Ten thoughts about last night's Press Awards

Walter Greenwood accepts the Journalists' Charity Special Award from Amy Williams and John Humphrys

i) The Telegraph and Will Lewis deserve all they got. Clearest winners for years.

ii) The red tops should get a better deal - particularly in sport.

iii) Walter Greenwood has saved a lot of journalists' skins and made an understated contribution to the industry. A thoroughly deserved award.

iv) In another year Jacqui Smith putting adult films on expenses would have walked away with Scoop of the Year.

v) Nick Ferrari should have been on stage instead of sipping (he had a 6am show in the morning) white wine on the judges' table.

vi) Boris Johnson should be a full-time comedian ... perhaps he is. Listen to his speech. 

vii) What no women? Speakers included many middle-aged men ... Bob Satchwell, Chris Boffey, Boris Johnson, Dominic Ponsford, John Humphrys ... but  only two non-journalist women cameos. Lady Cudlipp and Olympic slider Amy Williams.

viii) Double blow for Andrew Rawnsley ... didn't win and his name was spelt wrong in the programme. Ransle?

ix) Had the best table mates I could have wished for. Two women ex-editors (how rare are they?), Eve Pollard and Anita Syvret. Also David Banks, ex-Mirror editor, who is good craic and a generous man. Four bottles of wine at the end of the night ... £170. I owe him.

x) Enjoyable night, well done to all. A good show. Makes me even more depressed that the regional awards have been shelved.

Full list of winners